When giving oral reasons on paper, what is typically included in the first column?

In the context of giving oral reasons on paper, the first column is typically where the reasons for placing are articulated. This column serves to provide a detailed rationale that supports the rankings or placements that the judge or evaluator has assigned. It is essential for conveying the logic behind decisions made during the evaluation process, demonstrating clear and objective reasoning that is rooted in the characteristics of the entries being judged.

Including reasons for placing helps to ensure transparency in the judging process and allows others to understand the basis for decisions. It reflects an understanding of the criteria used for assessment and shows how specific traits or qualities led to the final placements made. This foundational column is crucial, as it establishes the judge's thought process and assists in clarifying the evaluation to both peers and participants.

The other aspects mentioned, such as judging criteria, personal opinions, or final placements, are typically documented in different sections of the oral reasons or are provided in subsequent columns. Judging criteria would generally define the standards against which the entries are assessed rather than justify the specific placements. Personal opinions, while they may inform a judge’s perspective, should not be the focus in formal reasons—objectivity is key. The final placement assessment is usually a summary or conclusion that reflects the rankings, rather than the reasoning